A skill-based ability in a deterministic world entails only one possible future action; 'able to do X' implies X was genuinely possible—not just what would happen if conditions differed.

?Rate how convincing each reason is below to see the overall strength.

No one has weighed in yet. Be the first to share reasons for or against this statement.

Deterministic world(as used in metaphysics): A universe where every event is caused by previous events in an unbroken chain, leaving no room for randomness or uncaused choices.
Free will vs. determinism debate(as the underlying tension in this statement): The long-running philosophical argument about whether humans can make truly free choices or whether everything we do is predetermined by prior causes.
Modal language(as used in the phrase 'X was genuinely possible' in logic): Talking about what is possible, impossible, necessary, or contingent—basically discussing what *could* happen versus what *must* happen.
Skill-based ability(as used in philosophy of action): Being able to do something because you've practiced and developed competence in it, like being able to play guitar or solve math problems.

Based on where you are in your exploration