Adams correctly identifies a performative inconsistency: if God's 'larger picture' justifies permitting evil, the same logic should justify utilitarian policies that maximize overall good.

?Rate how convincing each reason is below to see the overall strength.

No one has weighed in yet. Be the first to share reasons for or against this statement.

Adams(as the philosopher whose theory is being discussed): Robert Adams is a philosopher who developed a theory of morality based on God's character—basically, he argues that what's good is whatever aligns with God's nature and desires.
Larger picture(as a theological justification for allowing suffering): The broader context or long-term consequences of something, rather than just looking at immediate effects.
Performative inconsistency(as a logical flaw in an argument): When someone's actions or logic contradict what they're claiming to believe—like saying you care about the environment but driving a gas-guzzler.
Utilitarian policies(as the type of reasoning being compared): Rules or decisions designed to create the greatest happiness or benefit for the greatest number of people overall.

Based on where you are in your exploration