An account that requires revising robust pre-theoretical perceptual data has a higher explanatory burden than one that accommodates them, undermining the Identity View's claimed preference.

?Rate how convincing each reason is below to see the overall strength.

No one has weighed in yet. Be the first to share reasons for or against this statement.

Accommodate(as used in disability rights and social justice): To adjust or modify something so that it works for someone's particular needs; for example, providing wheelchair ramps or sign language interpreters.
Explanatory burden(the philosophical problem being discussed): The responsibility to explain or justify something—if you move a problem from one place to another without really solving it, you've just relocated the explanatory burden.
Identity View(Philosophy of perception / metaphysics of sound): The position that sound is identical with its event source, i.e., sound is metaphysically reduced to the source event.
Perceptual data(as used in epistemology (study of knowledge)): The raw information your senses collect about the world—what you actually see, hear, feel, or experience in a given moment.

Based on where you are in your exploration