Dupré's promiscuous realism implies that protein classification is irreducibly pluralistic, meaning no single structural account can serve as the fundamental individuating principle across all legitimate scientific contexts.

?Rate how convincing each reason is below to see the overall strength.

No one has weighed in yet. Be the first to share reasons for or against this statement.

Dupré(as the originator of promiscuous realism): John Dupré is a philosopher of science who argued that our categories for organizing nature (like species or chemical elements) aren't discovered in nature itself—they're created based on what's useful for different purposes.
Individuating principle(what determines what proteins are): A rule or criterion that decides what makes something its own distinct thing—basically, what counts as one thing versus another.
Irreducibly pluralistic(describing protein classification): Something that cannot be simplified down to a single principle or system—it genuinely requires multiple different frameworks to fully understand.
Legitimate scientific contexts(the various situations where proteins might be classified differently): Different real-world scientific situations where valid scientific work is being done with different goals or methods.

Based on where you are in your exploration