George Dickie's institutional theory emerged precisely from recognizing that phenomenological definitions of the aesthetic are irremediably circular, suggesting the problem is structural, not incidental.

?Rate how convincing each reason is below to see the overall strength.

1 reason for

1 reason against

Reasons For

1 perspective

Reason for

1 perspective

Reason against

Based on where you are in your exploration

Circular (reasoning)(as used in logic and epistemology): A logical mistake where you prove something by assuming it's already true—like saying 'this is important because it's important.'
George Dickie(as the originator of the institutional theory of art): A 20th-century American philosopher who developed new ideas about what makes something art, focusing on the role of the art world and institutions rather than just how things look or feel.
Institutional theory(as a theory about what defines art): The idea that something counts as art because the art world—museums, galleries, critics, artists—treats it as art, rather than because of what it physically is.
Irremediably(as a description of the severity of the circular problem): In a way that cannot be fixed or corrected; hopelessly or beyond repair.
Phenomenological definitions(as definitions that focus on personal experience): Attempts to define something (like art or beauty) based on how it actually appears to our senses and feelings when we experience it directly.
Structural problem(contrasting with incidental problems): A flaw built into the basic framework or foundation of an idea, rather than just a minor mistake that could be easily fixed.
The aesthetic(as the subject of philosophical definitions): The quality of being beautiful, artistic, or related to how something looks and feels when we experience it.

1 topic