If deontological justification were sufficient for justified belief, then subjects who fulfill their deontic obligations would thereby have justified beliefs — but these cases show they do not.
(S's justification refers to why S has good reason to believe P3)
The reasons or evidence that make it reasonable for you to believe something is true.
justified belief(Coherence theory of justification)
A belief that is part of a coherent system of beliefs
sufficient condition(Used in the context of whether intrinsic properties can define species membership)
A property whose presence guarantees membership in or applicability of a category, such that having the property entails belonging to the species or class
According to the second objection to DJ, deontological justification cannot suffice for an agent to have a justified belief. This claim is typically supported by describing cases involving either a benighted, culturally isolated society or subjects who are cognitively deficient. Such cases involve subjects whose cognitive limitations make it the case that they are under no obligation to refrain from believing as they do, but whose limitations nonetheless render them incapable of forming justifie