Skip to content
Carmelics
TopicsThinkersChangesContributorsLoading account…

    Carmelics

    A reasoning platform. Break down any belief into clear reasons, explore both sides, and weigh the evidence honestly.

    Navigate

    • Topics
    • Search
    • Recent Changes
    • Contribute
    • How It Works
    • Glossary
    • Thinkers
    • Contributors
    • About
    • Statistics
    • Terms
    • Privacy

    Database

    Statements
    —
    Perspectives
    —
    Topics
    —

    Press ? for keyboard shortcuts

    LoyalLoyalJusticeJustice
    Made withinDC&Austin
    Statements
    321,452
    Perspectives
    108,905
    Topics
    42
    Democracy & Governance — Carmelics
    Topics/Political & Social Philosophy/Democracy & Governance

    Democracy & Governance

    Democratic theory, representation, and collective decision-making

    2,705 ideas in this topic

    829 of 2705 ideas have perspectives(31%)

    2,705 results
    Supports→Sound-mindedness is not doing one's own things.

    A city which ordered experts only to do their own things would not be sound-minded.

    40%
    premise

    Nations are entitled to their own states.

    55%
    claim

    Nations need to have their own states

    55%
    claim

    Secular rulers must be subject to the pope.

    55%
    claim

    The state must be neutral

    55%
    claim

    A Nazi seizure of power in legal form would not be legitimate.

    70%
    claim

    A background consensus based on cultural homogeneity is not needed as a catalyzing condition for democracy.

    70%
    claim

    A city comes to be

    70%
    claim
    Supports→A city which ordered experts only to do their own things would not be sound-minded.

    A city that is managed sound-mindedly is well-managed.

    55%
    premise
    Supports→A city which ordered experts only to do their own things would not be sound-minded.

    A city which ordered such experts only to do their own things would not be well-managed.

    55%
    premise

    A conception of global justice can be detached from concerns with legitimacy

    70%
    claim

    A conception of international order that fails to accommodate a plurality of self-determined political identities or fails to recognize the ius ad bellum of constituted political communities is illegitimate.

    70%
    claim

    A constitutional monarch's explicit 'I will' is necessary to express the general will in legislation.

    70%
    claim

    A controversial conception of human capabilities may nonetheless be appropriately imposed through government policy if that conception is true and known to be true

    70%
    claim

    A counsellor should engage in public affairs using civil philosophy (civilior) rather than withdraw

    70%
    claim

    A decentralized market system has informational advantages over centralized coordination

    70%
    claim

    A democracy ought to protect the democratic process for moral reasons that must be grounded in the principles underpinning democracy itself.

    70%
    claim

    A democratic constitution based on popular sovereignty must recognize limits to constitutional amendment.

    70%
    claim

    A developmental theory of history is not distinctive of the liberal tradition

    ?
    claim

    A global equality requirement is deeply counterintuitive

    70%
    claim

    A good ruler will display restraint and moderation despite divinely mandated power.

    70%
    claim

    A government must separate executive, legislative, and judicial powers in order to provide citizens with the greatest possible liberty.

    70%
    claim

    A great democracy must either sacrifice self-government to achieve unity or preserve self-government through federalism.

    70%
    claim

    A just society should give priority to strictly protecting both basic liberties and FEO.

    70%
    claim

    A king who follows the path of moderation is rewarded both temporally and eternally.

    70%
    claim

    A large council of citizens should deliberate with and hold the monarch accountable as a central constitutional check.

    70%
    claim

    A later case should only be treated differently from an earlier case when the law itself has been changed.

    70%
    claim

    A legitimate international order must recognize as legitimate the ius ad bellum claimed by all groups that have successfully constituted themselves as political communities.

    70%
    claim

    A liberal state can promote the good of its citizenry only in ways consistent with every reasonable conception of the good

    70%
    claim

    A limited Platonic spirit survives in Aristotle's ideal regime

    70%
    claim

    Thinkers in this topic

    Amartya Sen2David Estlund2Edward Blyden2James T. Holly2
    Joseph Raz
    2
    Martin Delany2
    Rainer Forst2
    Robert Goodin2
    The Romantics2
    A. John Simmons1
    A. V. Dicey1
    Abbé de Saint-Pierre1

    Glossary

    knowledge

    Justified true belief — true belief that has been arrived at through the exercise of deliberative capacities, including comparison of and deliberation among alternatives.

    Adjudication

    The process of a judge or court hearing a case and making a legal decision about it.

    Corruption

    When government officials or people in power abuse their position for personal gain—like taking bribes or stealing public money instead of using it to help their country.

    Democracy

    A political form that calls for the sharing of power, the giving of reasons, and universalization — requiring power to be exercised through communication in an assembly, yet also requiring force and sovereign decision.

    Disseminated

    Spread out or distributed among many different places, groups, or people rather than being concentrated in one location.

    International actors

    Countries, organizations, or entities that operate on a global level and influence world politics, like the United Nations or other global bodies.

    Median

    The middle value in a list of numbers—if you line up all the grades from lowest to highest, the median is the one in the middle.

    Nation-state

    A country with defined borders and a government that has authority over the people and territory within it.

    Related Topics

    Rights & Liberty3884Social Contract2399

    Connected Topics

    Topics that share ideas with Democracy & Governance

    Social Contract605 sharedRights & Liberty599 sharedJustice & Punishment221 sharedTruth & Knowledge190 sharedVirtue Ethics162 sharedConsequentialism151 sharedPhilosophy of Language103 sharedMoral Responsibility69 shared

    Help Build This Topic

    1876 propositions still need supporting arguments.