If the compulsive deliberator under hypnotic suggestion experiences genuine deliberative phenomenology yet lacks libertarian freedom, phenomenology underdetermines the power Reid claims it establishes.

?Rate how convincing each reason is below to see the overall strength.

No one has weighed in yet. Be the first to share reasons for or against this statement.

Compulsive deliberator(describing a person under hypnotic suggestion): Someone who is thinking through a decision or problem, but feels forced or driven to do so against their will.
Deliberative phenomenology(the subjective experience of deliberation): The actual felt experience of thinking through a choice or decision—what it feels like from the inside when you're deliberating.
Genuine: Something is genuine when it is real, authentic, and exactly what it claims to be—not fake, counterfeit, or pretending to be something else. For example, genuine leather is actual leather rather than synthetic material, or a genuine apology comes from sincere feeling rather than obligation. The word describes anything that is honestly and truly itself without deception or imitation.
Hypnotic suggestion(as the condition affecting the deliberator): An instruction or idea planted in someone's mind while they're in a hypnotic state, which they may follow without consciously choosing to.

Based on where you are in your exploration