Where a creature freely and persistently repudiates the relationship, the relational basis for forgiveness as a binding obligation dissolves, as even Marilyn McCord Adams acknowledges in distinguishing horrendous evil from ordinary wrongdoing.

?Rate how convincing each reason is below to see the overall strength.

No one has weighed in yet. Be the first to share reasons for or against this statement.

Binding obligation(as what forgiveness may or may not be, depending on the relationship): A duty or responsibility that you're genuinely required to fulfill—something morally necessary, not optional.
Horrendous evil(as distinguished from ordinary wrongdoing in debates about forgiveness): Extreme, devastating suffering or wrongdoing that seems so terrible it can't be justified or made right—think genocide, torture, or child abuse rather than everyday harms.
Marilyn McCord Adams(as a cited philosopher in discussions of evil and forgiveness): A contemporary American philosopher who specializes in theology and philosophy of religion, known for her work on how God relates to human suffering and evil.
Relational basis(as what dissolves when forgiveness can no longer be required): The foundation of a connection or relationship between two people; the reasons or conditions that make a relationship exist.

Based on where you are in your exploration