Skip to content
Carmelics
TopicsThinkersChangesContributorsLoading account…

    Carmelics

    A reasoning platform. Break down any belief into clear reasons, explore both sides, and weigh the evidence honestly.

    Navigate

    • Topics
    • Search
    • Recent Changes
    • Contribute
    • How It Works
    • Glossary
    • Thinkers
    • Contributors
    • About
    • Statistics
    • Terms
    • Privacy

    Database

    Statements
    —
    Perspectives
    —
    Topics
    —

    Press ? for keyboard shortcuts

    LoyalLoyalJusticeJustice
    Made withinDC&Austin
    Statements
    321,452
    Perspectives
    108,905
    Topics
    42
    Religious Experience — Carmelics
    Topics/Philosophy of Religion/Religious Experience

    Religious Experience

    Experiential evidence for religious claims

    844 ideas in this topic

    277 of 844 ideas have perspectives(33%)

    844 results

    The transition from classical to romantic art represents a liberation of art from religion and of religion from art and the sensuous.

    55%
    claim

    There is no need to suppose that religious beliefs are true

    ?
    claim

    A belief that depends on historical or scientific approximation would not be genuine faith.

    70%
    claim

    A claim of direct divine experience must be accepted if it is well founded and grips the heart completely

    70%
    claim

    A convincing claim of divine contact with flesh and blood requires four criteria of evidence

    70%
    claim

    A morality founded on religion is a necessary concomitant of a revealed religion.

    70%
    claim

    A mystic who undergoes a PCE can recall immediately afterward the awareness that was present during the PCE

    70%
    claim

    A person who experiences God through moral experience may have reasonable belief in God without a moral argument

    70%
    claim

    A scientist can be a believer in religious tenets

    70%
    claim

    A subject cannot surmise that a PCE occurred by remembering a 'before' and an 'after' with an unaccounted-for middle period.

    ?
    claim

    Abraham's obedience to God's command cannot be adjudicated by public reason

    70%
    claim

    Acceptance of theistic hope provides reason to act as if theism were true

    70%
    claim

    Accepting a foundational faith-proposition is an all-or-nothing commitment, not a matter of degree

    70%
    claim

    Accurate divination from dreams requires proper interpretation by a diviner

    70%
    claim

    Acting as if a religious tradition were true includes engaging in its rituals and investing time and money in its associated causes

    70%
    claim

    Action cannot produce liberation because liberation is already one's present reality, not a future attainment.

    ?
    claim

    Adherents of non-Christian religions can enter God's presence even without awareness of Jesus's redemptive acts.

    70%
    claim

    All beings, including non-sentient things like grasses, trees, and the land itself, hold the potential for awakening.

    70%
    claim

    Alston's argument for the rationality of Christian doxastic practice can be undermined.

    ?
    claim

    Alston's argument for the rationality of Christian religious-experience practice may also justify other religious doxastic practices.

    70%
    claim

    Alston's inference from practical rationality to epistemic rationality is illegitimate.

    ?
    claim

    An ordinary emotion such as gratitude becomes religious when combined with the feeling of absolute dependence.

    70%
    claim

    An ordinary person who is aware of moral obligations has a kind of de re awareness of God.

    70%
    claim

    Any conceivable divine revelation must choose its means from a restricted list of discreet evidences (e.g., sense of divine presence, internal communication such as dreams and visions, fulfilled prophecies, Resurrection, Incarnation).

    70%
    claim

    Anybody who meets certain requirements will automatically become a prophet.

    70%
    claim

    Apologetic arguments are not necessary for proper faith, nor the epistemic basis for faith.

    70%
    claim

    Aristoxenus is not simply rationalizing Pythagoreanism

    ?
    claim

    Attempting to gain or reach liberation while presupposing its distance causes liberation to recede further rather than approach.

    ?
    claim

    Authentic religious sentiment is more likely to be found in nature than in a church

    70%
    claim

    Average people need virtuous guidance from a prophet to live in accordance with truth.

    70%
    claim

    Thinkers in this topic

    David Silver1F. Schlegel1J.L. Schellenberg1John Hick1
    Kenneth Einar Himma
    1
    Philip Quinn1
    William Alston1
    William Hasker1

    Glossary

    knowledge

    Justified true belief — true belief that has been arrived at through the exercise of deliberative capacities, including comparison of and deliberation among alternatives.

    epistemology

    A normative enterprise that tells us how we ought to reason from evidence and how we ought to justify our beliefs, as distinct from merely describing how we do reason or justify beliefs

    religious experience

    A personal encounter or moment that someone interprets as connecting them to God or the sacred—like feeling God's presence, having a vision, or experiencing a sense of the divine.

    stood the test of time

    Proved to be reliable, useful, or true by continuing to work well over many years or centuries.

    Buddha

    Buddha refers to Siddhartha Gautama, a spiritual teacher who lived in ancient India around 2,500 years ago and founded Buddhism, one of the world's major religions. He's called "the Buddha," meaning "the Awakened One" or "the Enlightened One," because he claimed to have discovered a path to end human suffering through meditation and ethical living. Buddhists follow his teachings, which emphasize that suffering comes from desire and attachment, and that anyone can achieve inner peace and enlightenment by following his practices.

    Empirical evidence

    Information or proof based on real-world observation and experience, rather than just theory or reasoning alone.

    Sense-experience

    Knowledge that comes directly from your five senses—what you see, hear, touch, taste, or smell.

    divine revelation

    Knowledge of God's true essence disclosed through the Torah and Jewish tradition, as opposed to philosophical demonstration.

    Related Topics

    Eternal Conscious Torment453Against an aspect of God242Against a future action of God77Proof of definition segments1659All sources support it595No other argument is better65Annihilation208Against an attribute of God416

    Connected Topics

    Topics that share ideas with Religious Experience

    Truth & Knowledge247 sharedNatural Theology130 sharedSkepticism79 sharedDivine Attributes67 sharedPhilosophy of Language52 sharedConsciousness & Mind40 sharedVirtue Ethics31 sharedAesthetics20 shared

    Help Build This Topic

    567 propositions still need supporting arguments.