Skip to content
Carmelics
TopicsThinkersChangesContributorsLoading account…

    Carmelics

    A reasoning platform. Break down any belief into clear reasons, explore both sides, and weigh the evidence honestly.

    Navigate

    • Topics
    • Search
    • Recent Changes
    • Contribute
    • How It Works
    • Glossary
    • Thinkers
    • Contributors
    • About
    • Statistics
    • Terms
    • Privacy

    Database

    Statements
    —
    Perspectives
    —
    Topics
    —

    Press ? for keyboard shortcuts

    LoyalLoyalJusticeJustice
    Made withinDC&Austin
    Statements
    321,452
    Perspectives
    108,905
    Topics
    42
    Insubordination to God — Carmelics
    Topics/Philosophy of Religion/Insubordination to God

    Insubordination to God

    Arguments about rebellion or disobedience toward God

    101 ideas in this topic

    31 of 101 ideas have perspectives(31%)

    101 results

    Insubordination is the true "Hell."

    40%
    claim

    Abraham's duty to obey God's command supersedes both social duty and personal commitment, requiring action that cannot be justified by social norms.

    70%
    claim

    All agency belongs to God and God alone

    70%
    claim

    Christian rulers should not propagate the Christian religion through armed force

    ?
    claim

    Conservative institutional leaders in Tibet during the later diffusion period sought to correct errors, especially those that upset tantric hierarchies

    70%
    claim

    Ecclesial mediation of piety has a worldly impact that may interfere with the state's functions.

    70%
    claim
    Challenges→InsubordinationE is the true "Hell."

    Eventually, everyone will accept God

    35%
    claim

    Feuerbach's humanism intensifies the tyranny of the divine over the individual compared to traditional theism.

    ?
    claim

    Grumbling at the way things are is evidence of impiety

    70%
    claim

    Human beings are capable of falling from grace

    70%
    claim

    Human beings ought to be willing to sacrifice their own happiness for God if God were to require it

    70%
    claim

    InsubordinationE is the true "Hell."

    40%
    claim

    It is idolatrous to attribute divine power to creatures.

    ?
    claim

    It is possible for God to demand a suspension of socially prescribed ethical norms

    70%
    claim

    Laws should not concern offenses against God

    70%
    claim

    Natural theology is either insincere or sinful.

    ?
    claim

    Reason's ignorantia Dei is an active neglecting of God

    70%
    claim

    The chief may publish the maxim that rebellion will be sanctioned with death without self-frustration.

    70%
    claim

    The pope cannot be the supreme temporal ruler

    70%
    claim

    The pope should not direct the secular ruler even though the Church concerns the highest end

    ?
    claim

    The prince should not intervene in the internal affairs of the church or meddle with doctrinal issues.

    70%
    claim

    When reason and will malfunction, synderesis is effectively overthrown and the agent sins.

    70%
    claim

    A free choice involves fully understanding the nature of the choice

    ?
    claim

    If one is to reject God, they must believe a lie

    ?
    conditional
    Challenges→Insubordination is the true "Hell."

    It is not that Insubordination is consistent with the justice of God

    ?
    claim
    Challenges→Insubordination is the true "Hell."

    It is not that Insubordination lines up with Scripture

    ?
    claim

    those who eventually accept God will never reject Him again

    ?
    claim

    A prophet cannot avoid being persecuted and put to death

    70%
    claim

    If the above is true, we have the true version of the Orthodox Christian Hell in our knowledge

    ?
    conclusion
    Supports→Annihilation is the true Hell+2

    No other version of Hell is better

    ?
    claim

    Thinkers in this topic

    Abbot Ubertino of Otranto1Adam1Antonius Arquatus1Aristotle1
    Averroes
    1
    Bernardino Telesio1
    Francesco Pucci1
    Galen1
    Galileo Galilei1
    Giambattista della Porta1
    Giordano Bruno1
    Hermann Conring1

    Glossary

    Satan

    In Christian theology, the supreme evil being or devil who opposes God and leads souls toward sin and damnation.

    argument from self-valuation

    A reasoning process that says: if you think your own characteristics are valuable, then by that same logic, other beings should be able to think their characteristics are valuable too.

    by the same reasoning

    A logical principle meaning that if a rule or argument works in one situation, it should work the same way in similar situations—you can't apply rules unfairly to different cases.

    devilish nature

    The qualities or characteristics that make something evil or harmful; used here to contrast with human nature.

    knowledge

    Justified true belief — true belief that has been arrived at through the exercise of deliberative capacities, including comparison of and deliberation among alternatives.

    personhood

    A status achievable through moral achievement, contingent on the exercise of the capacity for virtue.

    Related Topics

    Eternal Conscious Torment453Against an aspect of God242Against a future action of God77Proof of definition segments1659All sources support it595No other argument is better65Annihilation208Against an attribute of God416

    Connected Topics

    Topics that share ideas with Insubordination to God

    Moral Responsibility16 sharedDivine Attributes13 sharedSocial Contract10 sharedDemocracy & Governance4 sharedVirtue Ethics4 sharedNatural Theology4 sharedJustice & Punishment4 sharedUniversalism3 shared

    Help Build This Topic

    70 propositions still need supporting arguments.